Simplifying Tax Law: Why India’s Government Withdrew the Income Tax Bill 2025 — and What Comes Next

Introduction: Change on the Horizon for India’s Tax Law

In a bid to overhaul India’s six-decade-old Income-Tax Act of 1961, the government introduced the Income Tax Bill, 2025 early this year. However, in a surprising turn, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman recently withdrew the bill from the Lok Sabha. A new version—reflecting key revisions—is now scheduled for reintroduction on August 11, 2025

Let’s explore why the bill was retracted, what fixes are being made, and what taxpayers can anticipate next.

1. Why Was the Income Tax Bill Withdrawn?

The original bill, introduced on February 13, 2025, aimed to bring clarity and simplification to India’s complex tax code. It was meant to replace the exhaustive Income-Tax Act, 1961.

However, after review by a 31-member select committee, several drafting issues came to light—such as unclear language, misaligned clauses, and potentially unfair tax interpretations. To avoid confusion caused by multiple versions, the government withdrew the bill and opted for a clean, consolidated rewrite

2. Key Fixes Recommended by Experts & the Select Committee

The select committee, chaired by MP Baijayant Panda, flagged several critical areas needing correction:

  • A. House Property Clauses (Clauses 21 & 22)
    • Suggested removing vague phrasing such as “in normal course.”
    • Recommended detailing how to compare actual rent with deemed rent more clearly.
    • Advised that standard 30% deductions be calculated after deducting municipal taxes.
    • Expanded deductions on pre-construction interest to include rented properties
  • B. Salaried Income & Pension Clauses (Clause 19)
    • Introduced the right for non-employees receiving commuted pension to claim deductions under "income from other sources"—matching benefits available to salaried employees
  • C. Commercial Property Definition (Clause 20)
    • Clarified language to prevent misclassifying property types by shifting wording from “occupied” to “as he may occupy”.
  • D. Other Adjustments
    • Restored tax exemption on anonymous donations to purely religious trusts (but not to those engaged in charitable work like hospitals or schools).
    • Allowed taxpayers to get TDS refunds even after the ITR filing due date, without penalties.

3. What’s the Bill’s Goal? A Simpler, Fairer Tax System

The revamped Income Tax Bill, 2025 is part of a broader effort to simplify India’s income tax framework. The 1961 law—spanning 500,000+ words and subject to over 4,000 amendments—has become unwieldy.

Now, policymakers aim to build a modern tax law—clear, accessible, and equitable—especially for middle-class taxpayers, MSMEs, and small businesses. The focus is on:

  • Reducing complexity
  • Strengthening transparency
  • Enhancing taxpayer convenience
  • Reducing litigation and ambiguities.

Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju confirmed that, while amendments have been incorporated, the bill still retains the core intent of simplifying tax laws and modernizing compliance for the digital age.

4. What to Expect After August 11

On August 11, Parliament will see the updated bill that includes all key revisions. If passed, this will lay the legal foundation for a simplified, taxpayer-centric income tax structure in India. It could redefine how personal, business, and property incomes are taxed going forward.

Summary Table: Old vs Revised Income Tax Bill, 2025

Feature Original Draft Revised Version (Expected)
Drafting Clarity Vague positions Accurate language, clear definitions
House Property Treatment Ambiguous rules Specified thresholds and computation methods
Pension Deductions Restricted Broadened to include non-employees
Anonymous Donations Disallowed Exempted for purely religious trusts
TDS Refund Policy Deadline-bound Allowed post-filing without penalties
Taxpayer Impact Complex Simplified, more accessible

Final Thoughts: A Positive Step for Tax Compliance

By rolling back and rewriting the Income Tax Bill, 2025, the government has shown its commitment to precision, fairness, and responsiveness. This effort promises a cleaner, more understandable tax law—designed for the modern digital taxpayer.

For businesses, accountants, and taxpayers alike, the upcoming version could mean simpler filing, clearer rules, and fewer disputes.

WhatsApp
Book Your Free Consultation